I would rather have more dmg and P def same as tyrr DK , than having mana shield which is useless,
Without rose solo farm example:
With DK 108 I farm easily solo in field of silence (+10 blessed exalted set with ruby Lv4/red cat lv3 rest are greater gems, top book +3, radiant +3, some artifacts +3, limited +12 cloack +10)
With feoh 113 similar gear in field of silence with (x4 greater gems saph/cats/emeral/diamond +12 limited , +10 blessed set, +3 radiant, +2 rind, top book +3, some artifacts +3 cloack +10)
And with DK I farm without rose with no sweat ,
with feoh if I use mana barrier I die due to MP as its gone within minutes,
if I don't use mana barrier I have to step 20 metre away from mobs and gamble if I will be alive after few hours as if more than x3 mobs will reach me before they die I'm dead...
So dont tell me that "mana barrier" is OP as F... as it is piece of sh.. even on PVE,
farm blue mobs with mana barrier maybe ok... with 113 feoh in Aligator or Tanor (108 farm zone) yeah you can solo... 5lvl lower spots..